It’s possible to have different kinds of flooring throughout the house, and it is sometimes encouraged to keep your home from feeling boring. It can be difficult to decide between carpet and hardwood for your bedrooms, regardless of the flooring in the rest of the house. Broadly speaking, there really isn’t a wrong answer. But your unique home might benefit from one over the other. We have carefully researched whether or not you should have carpet or hardwood in your bedroom.
Disclosure: We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.
There are benefits and disadvantages when you choose either carpeting or hardwood floors for your bedroom. You will have to weigh these features against the personal needs of your own home:
- Carpeting is more comfortable
- Carpets are less expensive
- Carpet floors won’t show damage
- Hardwood is easier to clean
- Wood flooring is highly durable
- Hardwood floors have a flexible style
Bedrooms are a private space where you can add a lot of your own personality with no regard for guests. But you’ll still need to consider function as well as style. Keep reading to learn about the most important differences between carpets and hardwood such as health benefits, price tags, and insulation.
Carpet vs Hardwood in the Bedroom
Most of the time, your bedrooms will have the same flooring as the rest of the home. Only the bathrooms and kitchens will be unique, in order to focus on water resistant floors. But it is actually possible to have up to three different kinds of flooring in your home.
The bedrooms just need to remain consistent with each other, as well as the overall style of the home. From there, you can choose between carpet or hardwood no matter what. It will come down to personal needs and style preferences. It’s best to prepare for an informed decision because no matter what, adding a new floor is always going to demand a lot of time and effort.
Carpeting is more comfortable
Naturally, carpet is going to be softer than hardwood, which announces its toughness right in the name. If you tend to go to bed barefoot, then you may not necessarily want to walk around a hardwood floor when you turn in for the night.
Regardless of what you wear on your feet, carpets are always easier to walk across. Although an underlay can be added beneath hardwood floors, carpeting is always its own cushion. Carpeting still needs underlayment to preserve the lifespan, but the fibers will absorb daily foot traffic.
You can even purchase a different carpet “pile” to increase comfort. A carpet’s pile is the name for the texture and height of the fibers. For example, you can decide on a high, looped pile for a thick and cozy carpet. Meanwhile, all hardwood flooring is flat and stiff.
You should also consider that carpeting can offer better insulation than hardwood floors, regarding both noise and temperature. You won’t hear footsteps or dropped objects nearly as much as a hardwood floor, which basically acts as an echoing soundboard. And the carpet fibers are much warmer to step on compared to hardwood, no matter how the surface of the wood is treated.
Do Hardwood Floors Make Your House Colder?
Specialists agree that carpets are great insulators. So, they are always ideal barriers between the coldness of the subfloor and the surface layer you actually use. The subfloor is generally made of concrete for stability, but that often absorbs the coldness beneath your home.
Your feet will thank you during the winter season, or in naturally cold climates, because carpets are able to retain warmth. When you turn up the thermostat, your carpets will make sure the heat doesn’t go anywhere.
Unfortunately, hardwood isn’t an insulator and won’t provide the same results. In that way, hardwood floors won’t keep your house as warm over time. So once again, carpets are particularly useful in a bedroom if you are likely to move around without footwear.
Is It Cheaper To Install Carpet Or Hardwood?
There are a lot of things that can change the price tag of your flooring. It might be your area, the thickness of your carpet, or the species of your hardwood. But generally speaking, buying a carpet is going to be cheaper than going with real, solid wood.
After all, hardwood needs to be retrieved from nature, while carpeting can easily be fabricated. So although one of the highlights of hardwood is its value, that is also one of its weaknesses. Carpeting will typically work for a smaller budget because the materials are cheaper to sell, and the installation isn’t as complicated.
It’s possible that you’re looking into laminate, floating floors, that only need to be installed using a simple tongue and groove system. Those involve individual pieces that lock right together and aren’t even nailed into the floor. But it isn’t purely natural wood. Actual hardwood floors have a very challenging installation process that absolutely needs to last.
Meanwhile, carpeting is available as inexpensive rolls, which just need an underlay and some tack strips. Some carpets are available with additional cushioning built right into the base.
Carpet floors won’t show damage
Hardwood can absolutely look gorgeous, but not when it gets damaged. It is very easy to notice when hardwood floors take a scrape or two because of the flat and neutral surface. The slightest dent will be a permanent fixture until you put in the money and effort to repair the damage.
However, fibers on a carpet won’t show any kind of damage. If you have children or pets running around the bedrooms, there’s likely to be some sort of noticeable accident. Or, your bedroom might double as a workspace for DIY projects and artwork. In these situations, it’s best to remember that hardwood is vulnerable and showcases dings.
Which Is Healthier In The Bedroom: Carpet Or Hardwood?
This is a big area where hardwood has a serious advantage over carpeting. Hardwood has a smooth surface that won’t collect much of anything, making it much easier to clean. Some light sweeping can take care of any dust. And there are plenty of commercial cleaners that will quickly remove stains.
Unfortunately, carpeting comes with big drawbacks because the fibers will naturally absorb anything. Stains are notoriously difficult to remove from carpeting, even when you have a low and cut pile carpet.
This can have a large impact on the health of the room. An expert group of international home inspectors, InterNACHI, also advise that carpeting has a high risk for mold growth.
Mold is a fungus that develops from stored moisture over time. This can lead to severe respiratory issues. Carpets will also collect and retain dust mites, which are terrible for people with allergies. Even when you vacuum the carpet, plenty of dust is simply kicked into the air.
The only places where hardwood can develop mold and mildew fungi are in areas with frequent water damage, such as kitchens and bathrooms. And hardwood does not let dust cling to the surface. So overall, hardwood floors are often considered healthier than carpeting. If you already have carpeting, you can read the post How Often Should You Wash Your Carpet? to help prevent some natural health issues.
Wooden flooring is highly durable
Yes, wooden floors are a big investment. But that’s because hardwood is also unusually durable. The typical lifespan of a hardwood floor can easily stretch for decades. You can often subject hardwood floors to constant foot traffic without having to worry about wearing them down. Some species of wood are actually more resistant to scratches, and adding the right finish can protect them for ages.
Carpeting doesn’t have equivalent surface protection. So carpet fibers will always flatten over time, and the cushioning will start to feel less comfortable. In fact, the fibers will also likely lose their color sooner than they actually wear out.
Hardwood floors have a flexible style
It may not seem like it, but hardwood flooring can be more versatile than carpets. True, the wooden look won’t work with as many interior design styles as carpets can. But wooden floors still agree with plenty of designs, and they are much easier to restyle.
Carpets will have to be replaced if you decide to change the color of your floor. But hardwood can simply be buffed down so you can apply a brand new stain. Without much trouble, your floor can be transformed from a cozy dark walnut into a bright white oak. You can read this post, How To Change Hardwood Floor Color [3 Quick Steps To Follow], to find out how easy this process really is.
Also, you’ll have the freedom to add any kind of area rug you could imagine. Area rugs can easily be moved or replaced, to better suit new bedroom ideas. Meanwhile, carpeting would have to be removed altogether, every time.
And don’t forget that hardwood floors are so smooth, they can often make the room feel more spacious. Unless you use a darker shade of wood, the flat surface of hardwood floors can really open up the room.
Can You Put Different Floorings In A Bedroom?
Most of the time, it isn’t a good idea to use different floorings between bedrooms. Instead, all of the bedrooms in a home should probably match. As mentioned above, it’s best to limit your home’s different floorings to a maximum of three. This keeps the home from feeling too busy.
But keep in mind that your kitchens and bathrooms are highly likely to demand special, tiled floors. This will help prevent water damage from warping wood or causing mold to grow in carpets.
This means that you’ve probably already used up two different floors just to accommodate the kitchens and bathrooms. Even if the kitchen shares an open floor plan with the living room and dining room, the bathroom usually has its own flooring.
However, so long as your bedrooms remain consistent with each other, and do not exceed the rule of three, it is possible to give them a different flooring from the rest of the home.
There are a vast number of differences between carpets and hardwood. But not all of them are immediately noticeable, even if they have a large impact on the health and style of your bedroom. Now that you can successfully weigh the advantages of each floor type against each other, you’ll be able to create a perfectly comfortable bedroom no matter what your conditions are.