Epoxyshield vs. Rocksolid: Which is Better? [Pros, Cons & Differences Explained]

Are you tired of looking at your dull and uninspiring garage floor? Do you want to give it a new lease on life with a fresh coating?

Then you've come to the right place!

In this article, we will dive into the world of Rust-Oleum's garage floor coatings and compare two popular options: EpoxyShield and Rocksolid.

EpoxyShield is known for its durability and scratch-resistant properties.

On the other hand, Rocksolid boasts an impressive 96% solids content by volume, making it even more durable.

But which one is right for you?

To answer that question, we'll take you through the pros, cons, and differences of each, so you can decide which suits your needs.

Let's start!

What is Epoxyshield Coating?

Epoxyshield is a two-part water-based epoxy coating that is designed to be used on concrete garage floors.

If you want to give your concrete floors a fresh and durable coating, EpoxyShield is a great option.

When applied correctly, EpoxyShield delivers a glossy, durable finish that will elevate the look and functionality of your garage. 

However, it's important to note that your floors must be in good condition and free of sealers or curing agents before applying the coating.

If you have poorly adhered previous coatings or moisture problems, it's best to avoid using EpoxyShield. 

See Rust-Oleum EpoxyShield on Amazon.

Facts About Rust-Oleum EpoxyShield

• It's essential to prioritize surface preparation. Check for poorly bonded paint, moisture, sealed concrete, and loose concrete.
• EpoxyShield's coating contains 52% solids by volume, making it a high-quality and durable option for concrete surfaces.
• The TDS provides guidelines for mixing and application. Using a brush before using a roller for the rest of the flooring is recommended.
• Light foot traffic is allowed within 12 to 16 hours of drying time, while regular traffic should be within 24 or 48 hours.
• The dry times are based on a 50% relative humidity and temperature of 70°F. 
• Follow the TDS guidelines for coating limitations, such as avoiding direct sunlight or temperatures below 60°F or above 85°F.

How to Use Epoxyshield Coating?

Applying EpoxyShield to your garage floor is a simple and straightforward process. Here's how:

1. First, prepare the surface by ensuring it is clean and debris-free.
2. Next, mix the components according to the instructions provided.
3. Finally, apply the coating in manageable 4x4 foot sections using a roller. 

For the best results with EpoxyShield, it's essential to prioritize surface preparation.

You Might Also Like: What’s The Best Garage Floor Coating?

What is Rocksolid Coating?

If you're looking for a long-lasting coat with a sleek finish, then Rocksolid is your best bet.

It's made from a Polycuramine formula and resin coating designed to provide superior adhesion and strength.

According to Rust-Oleum, Polycuramine is an impressive 20 folds sturdier than any other epoxy, resulting in a virtually indestructible finish.

With its exceptional strength and durability, Rocksolid is a great option for anyone seeking a high-performing finish for their concrete floors.

Another standout feature of Polycuramine is its environmental and health benefits.

Thanks to its minimal odor and reduced VOC (Volatile Organic Compounds) content, it's more pleasant to work with and safer for indoor use.

Rocksolid coating is available in various colors, including gray, tan, black, modern garage, and mocha.

See Rust-Oleum Rocksolid on Amazon.

Facts About Rust-Oleum Rocksolid

• RockSolid is a highly durable option. It is designed to be resistant to chemicals, oil, and gasoline.
• It has a low odor, which means you can use it for indoor applications.
• The 96% solids content gives you at least a week for recoating without the need for sanding.
• Foot traffic can be allowed within 10 hours, while vehicles can be resumed in about 24 to 36 hours.
• Depending on the condition and porosity of your concrete, each Polycuramine pouch can cover as much as 250 sq. ft.

How to Use Rocksolid Coating

Here's a step-by-step guide on how to use RockSolid coating:

1. Thoroughly clean and prepare the surface to be coated.
2. Mix the two components of the coating using the Easy Mix Burst Pouch Technology.
3. Apply the coating using a roller or brush, starting with the perimeter and working your way inward.
4. Allow the coating to dry and avoid exposure to water for at least seven days after application.

Also Read: How To Finish Garage Walls

Pros and Cons Epoxyshield vs. Rocksolid Coatings

Pros and Cons of Epoxyshield Coating

Epoxyshield is a well-known brand of DIY garage floor coatings. Here are some pros and cons to consider when choosing Epoxyshield:

Pros:

• Epoxyshield is one of the most recognized brands of garage floor coatings, and it has been around for nearly 40 years.
• With 52% solids content, it's an economical choice for homeowners who want to DIY their garage floor coating.
• Epoxyshield is resistant to spills and stains.

Cons:

• Epoxyshield is not as durable as Rocksolid, so it may not last as long as you would like.
• With its water-based formula, you shouldn't expect a high-gloss coating.
• The finish of Epoxyshield can be slippery when wet, which can be dangerous.

Pros and Cons of Rocksolid Coating

Rocksolid is a newer brand of garage floor coating that has been gaining popularity in recent years.

Here are some pros and cons to consider when choosing Rocksolid:

Pros:

• Rocksolid is known for its durability and scratch-resistant properties, which means it can last long.
• It is also resistant to chemicals, oil, and gasoline spills, which makes it an excellent choice for garages.
• It has a 7-day recoat window.
• The finish of Rocksolid is not as slippery as Epoxyshield when wet, which makes it safer.

Cons:

• Rocksolid is more expensive than Epoxyshield, which may not be suitable for those on a tight budget.
• It can also be harder to find in stores than Epoxyshield.

Related Article: Varathane Finish Vs. Minwax [Pros & Cons]

Key Differences of Epoxyshield Vs. Rocksolid Coatings

Epoxyshield and Rocksolid are two of the most popular options on the market.

While both coatings provide a durable and long-lasting finish, there are some key differences to consider before deciding.

Colors & Finishes

One of the biggest differences between Epoxyshield and Rocksolid is the range of colors and finishes available.

When you use Rocksolid to coat your garage floor, you can expect a solid base color with a stunning color-fleck finish that dries to a glossy shine.

It also offers various colors, including gray, tan, black, modern garage, and mocha.

Expoxyshield has a more limited color selection.

It may not offer the same level of shine as Rocksolid, but it still gives your garage a unique and textured finish that gives a professional look.

Application

While both coatings are DIY-friendly, the application process differs slightly.

Because Epoxyshield is a two-component water-based coating, you must mix an activator and a base, which can take 2-3 minutes.

Rocksolid, on the other hand, only requires one coat of Polycuramine coating.

Thus, the application process is quicker and easier.

Regarding curing time, Rocksolid is also quicker, requiring 10 hours to dry to resume foot traffic and 36 hours for vehicles.

Epoxyshield takes 16 hours to 48 hours of drying time.

Lifespan & Durability

When it comes to lifespan and durability, both coatings are top performers.

However, Rocksolid has a slightly longer lifespan and is more resistant to scratches and scuffs.

Epoxyshield, on the other hand, is more resistant to chemicals and stains.

Ultimately, the lifespan and durability of each coating will depend on how well you maintain your garage floor.

Cost

The cost of the coatings is another important factor to consider.

Epoxyshield is generally more affordable than Rocksolid, making it an excellent option for those on a budget.

However, Rocksolid's longer lifespan and durability may make it a better long-term investment.

Limitations

Both coatings are not recommended for use on floors with moisture issues as well as surfaces that have been previously coated with bonded paint.

Additionally, both coatings require a clean and smooth surface for proper adhesion.

Continue Reading: How To Tone Down Gold Finish [Different Ideas Explored]

Epoxyshield Vs. Rocksolid Coatings: Professional or DIY Installation

When it comes to installing garage floor coatings, you have two options: professional installation or DIY installation.

Both Epoxyshield and Rocksolid coatings are designed for DIY installation, but there are some differences to consider.

Epoxyshield coatings are relatively easy to install, but they require a bit of preparation.

You need to clean the surface thoroughly and ensure it's completely dry before applying the coating.

You also need to mix the two components of the coating together before applying it.

Rocksolid coatings, on the other hand, are even easier to install than Epoxyshield coatings.

They come in a single can, so you don't need to mix anything together.

You need to apply the coating to the surface and let it dry, making it an excellent option for those new to DIY projects.

If you're comfortable with DIY and have some experience with home improvement, either coating should be easy enough to install on your own.

The Verdict: Which is Better - Epoxyshield or Rocksolid Coatings?

When it comes to choosing between Epoxyshield and Rocksolid coatings, it ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences.

Both coatings have pros and cons, and it's up to you to decide which is better for your garage floor.

If you prioritize affordability and stain resistance, then choose Epoxyshield.

On the other hand, if you need a coating that's highly resistant to chemicals with a long-lasting coat, opt for Rocksolid.

With a 96% solids content by volume, it's a highly durable and flexible coating that can withstand heavy use and abuse.

Let us know what you think!

We'd love to hear your thoughts on which coating you prefer and why.